How we scoreBlogAdvertise
html›body›main#compare1,319 models · updated Nov 2, 2026
  1. compoundsemi.com
  2. Compare
  3. HM23 V2.0 vs Scout 3XT

Fenix HM23 V2.0 vs Silva Scout 3XT

What HM23 V2.0 does better (1) and where Scout 3XT wins (1) — every spec side by side.

Fenix HM23 V2.0
Fenix · 2024HM23 V2.0
7.4Score
1 advantage≈ $35
Higher score
vs
Silva Scout 3XT
Silva · 2023Scout 3XT
1 advantage≈ $30
3.9Brightness & throw3.5

Why is HM23 V2.0 better than Scout 3XT?

  1. Beam distance (ANSI FL1)88 m vs 65 m+35%

Why is Scout 3XT better than HM23 V2.0?

  1. Maximum output300 lm vs 350 lm+17%
Specifications

Side by side

Fenix HM23 V2.0Fenix HM23 V2.0≈ $357.4
Light output
Maximum output300 lm350 lm
Peak beam intensity1,940 cd—
Beam distance (ANSI FL1)88 m65 m
Light sourceLEDLED
LED & beam
LED emitterLuminus SST-20—
LED makerLuminus—
Colour temperature6,500K—
Battery & charging
Battery14500 Li-ion, AAAAA
Maximum runtime100 h—
RechargeableYes—
Build & durability
Water protection (IPx)IPx8—
Submersible to2 m—
Body materialStainless steelAluminium
Magnetic tail / baseYes—
Pocket clipYes—
Size & weight
Length / height73.6 mm—
Head diameter / width36 mm84 mm
Body diameter / depth30 mm—
Weight86 g—
Modes & features
Red lightYes—
LockoutYes—
Mode memoryYes—
ColoursBlack—
To compare: 0up to 4 models
Compare